Temptation—Genesis 2: 15-17; 3: 1-7; Matt. 4: 1-11
When it comes to temptation, nothing explains it more than a 4 year old testing his boundaries with a very tired parent. A few weeks ago my friend’s child was playing with some little Spiderman and Hulk figurines that stick to the wall when you throw them against it. There was, however, a minor problem. They tended to leave a small residue, looking a bit oily on the wall. So, there was a rule. You can ONLY, ONLY throw them against the wall in your room, not anywhere else in the house. Well, he happened to “accidentally” get it on a wall in the living room, and he was warned not to do it again by his mother.
He stood there, listening to her words, spending 20-30 seconds contemplating them in his mind and playing out all possible outcomes and ramifications. But the temptation was too great. In a very swift moment, he turned and threw the toy right on the living room wall, directly in violation of what his mother had just said. It only took seconds for a full chaotic pandemonium of him being headed straight to his room with full-fledged weeping, wailing, and gnashing of teeth at the reality of the consequences of his choices.
This theme will come up again and again in our readings for today. In Genesis, we hear of the immediate aftermath following the creation story. Adam and Eve are given everything they could want in the garden: food, perfection, each other, and God’s presence with them. There was just one limit. Do not eat of one tree which carries knowledge of good and evil. Unfortunately, humanity struggles with limits and boundaries, much like a riled up 4 year old at bedtime. I’ve seen it many times in life: a diabetic eating an extra helping of cake and the regret that follows, friends and family who don’t know when to stop teasing or arguing with one another, co-workers who show up on a kiss-cam at a Coldplay concert at a very unfortunate moment. Humanness causes us to test limits.
And yet we have to have limits in life. They protect us, preserve relationships, keep us employed and out of jail. God gives us boundaries of behavior and thought, not to make life dull, or take out the fun, but to protect us. The hardest part of maturing is realizing and accepting that every action we take has a consequence, whether good, bad, or both. For Adam and Eve, pushing the limits would inevitably strain their relationship with God and with one another.
We have to acknowledge, though, life isn’t so simple. Temptation is hard because, well, it’s tempting. I can safely say that I’ve never been tempted to do something miserable in life. We can ask why Even ate the fruit. We can ask how Jesus made it through the wilderness, but at the heart of both stories is the fact that temptation is sometimes less obvious to detect in life than we think. The snake was called crafty in Genesis. As humans we often are exposed to the shrewd and crafty elements of the world and all the best trained tricksters and deceivers that live here.
The snake doesn’t present as a villain. He’s polite, conversational, and presents nor causes any fear in Eve. Here’s the harder part. He told her the truth as well. She did not physically die from eating the fruit of the tree. It was her innocence and perfection which died. The truth was her eyes were opened to good and evil the same as God understands it. The problem is, Adam and Eve were not equipped to handle it. Whereas God can know all things, Adam and Eve were ruined by this knowledge. They tested the limits and what they found beyond the boundary was too much for them to handle as humans.
Likewise in Matthew’s Gospel, Satan presents in the same tricky and deceitful way. At no point does Satan lie to Jesus or misquote the scripture. And in some ways, that’s the hardest part. It’s easy to see through a bold face lie. It’s much harder to have discernment to know that even though what Satan said was truthful, it was still deceitful. As the Son of God, Jesus could easily make bread. After all, God created manna in the wilderness for the Hebrew people. When Satan tells Jesus to jump off the Temple as a show of power and authority, Satan quotes Psalm 91: 11-12. Satan quoted the scripture exactly, but deceitfully.
Let me give you an example that isn’t Jesus or the Garden of Eden. Summer before my senior year of high school, the few of us in AP English had to read 4-5 books and provide an analysis on them. We each took one and made detailed notes, so we didn’t have to read every single book. When asked about my analysis in class, I said, “I used the notes I had on the book to create the report and analyze the themes.” Truthful? Yes. Incredibly deceptive? Also, yes. Unfortunately, we do this in our relationships, our work, and to ourselves. A friend and fellow attorney once told me some wise advice about witnesses, “Just because the words they say are true does not mean they told the truth.”
The problem we have in both of these scriptures with temptation is what responsibility do we bear? Adam and Eve wouldn’t have eaten the fruit if Satan hadn’t tempted them through the snake. Jesus wouldn’t have been tempted if Satan hadn’t shown up to play his tricks. Are we mere pawns following whatever little enticement we can find, or are we fully culpable? A few commentators struggle with these scriptures because it allows us to say too much, “The devil made me do it,” without taking accountability for our behaviors and choices.
Two things are true at the same time. Humans are not the enemy of faith and life. There is an evil at work that is greater than we ourselves can do on our own. It’s easy to see people as evil, horrid, wretched. I remember at once church I played for, every service started with a prayer acknowledging that humans were “poor, wretched, miserable sinners.” That kind of belief is problematic when we also are told we are made in the image of God. We are often, though, easily influenced by evil and must turn back to the grace of Jesus to save us and keep us from doing what evil would tempt us to do.
But we also have to live with the consequences and accountability of our actions. If we over-indulge, we may become sick. If we use drugs and large amounts of alcohol, we may ruin our lives. If we cheat and give in to physical temptations, we may wreck our relationships. There is a difference in life between could and should. Could Jesus have made bread? Yes. Could Jesus have leapt from the Temple to prove his power? Yes. Could Jesus have given in to Satan’s trials because he was tired, hungry, and struggling? Yes. But the question is not “could.” It is should. And Jesus knew he should not do any of those things.
One of the hardest parts of being human is that temptation never goes away. It’s something we live with until we end our time here on earth. It’s a struggle we need Jesus to help us with every single day. We are no less tempted at 70 than we were at 25, it’s just the nature of the temptations change. But each and every day we can rely on God to help us with these struggles.
My friend’s child learned three things in rapid succession that evening: limits should not be tested, just because you can doesn’t mean you should, and choices in life have consequences. I dare say that at some point in life, we have all learned these lessons to one degree of difficulty or another. I want to leave you with some words from Anne Siddal of Stillpoint Spirituality, “Jesus, whose formation included wilderness, will be at our side to [help] us, will wipe away our tears, and place bread into the hands which have clutched at stones.” I pray this Lenten season that we will have the wisdom to rely on Jesus when we are bombarded by all the most alluring yet destructive temptations in life.
Worship Service Video https://www.facebook.com/fccmacon/videos/2366483777107503
